Skip to main content

#HistFicThursdays - A Significant Day For A Significant Age

I don't write many older characters. I suppose age - as with most things - is relative in fiction. When I began writing The Watcher's Heir  (my will-be-finished-one-day high fantasy epic), I was still at school and my hero began the story aged 25, an age I could not imagine ever reaching but an age I thought would still be considered young by many. If I ever manage to finish and edit that story, I'll be extending his - and a few others' - age! Having grown older, I've realised the advantages and the benefits of age. Of course, it's a bit of a disappointment that I'm never asked for ID in the shop anymore, or that people assume I'm my younger sisters' mother(!). But, on the whole, the pros have far outweighed the cons. The biggest con in terms of writing, is that it's difficult not to put an old head on young shoulders. Looking through books - both my own and those written by other people - it is clear just how easy it is to slip into the "ol...

#MGMonday #BookReview "Blue" by Caroline Allen

Bl u e

by Caroline Allen


What is the book about?

Maisie-Grace lives on the edge of a forest which suits her perfectly as she can talk to trees. Her best friend, Blue, is a Douglas Fir tree. Not only can she talk to trees, but she also has predicting dreams which she hides from her mum. When their landlord has to cut down the forest for logging, Maisie-Grace must try to save the trees.

Why this book?

Two reasons, really.

1) Environmental issues are important. More books need to be published with this message.

2) The blurb gave the impression of an exciting adventure story, and I do love a good upper middle grade adventure book that I can get my teeth into!

My thoughts

The book deals with a very important issue, which needs bringing to light around the world. Environmental issues is a theme I can get behind one hundred percent, and I think needs to be included in more children's books. 

I feel like the target age for this book is incorrect. Blue is marketed as a middle grade book, but there are several factors which make it more suitable for young adult. For instance, the level of teenage angst in the main character. Main character angst generally works better in young adult books as the target audience is dealing with changing bodies and hormones. At eleven, it is very possible that the main character is starting to go through puberty, but many eleven year olds (the target audience) won't yet understand the rollercoaster of feelings.

Truth be told, I found Maisie-Grace thoroughly unlikable. I found her mum irritating, but I felt sorry for her. She made moral sacrifices for her daughter, but her daughter was less than grateful. One thing that bothered me was how the mum asked the landlord if she could buy Blue, even though she didn't believe nature could be bought, and instead of thinking what a sacrifice her mum was making for her, the main character decided she wanted to save all of the trees, despite not being bothered about any of the others beforehand.

Aunt Angel was a lovely character, helping to get Maise-Grace ready for school and finding some tactics which could help her, although the main character was (again) ungrateful.

Personally, I found that this book was not for me. This could be simply a difference of culture. Being British, I am stereotypically less likely to warm to characters who spend too long feeling sorry for themselves. And, as my sisters can tell you from discussions arising about main characters in their stories, I am not a fan of Angst!

I do feel that readers who enjoy young adult books would enjoy this novel, and I think the target age group should be reconsidered for marketing purposes. I know this would mean changing the age of the main character but I think, if another edition of this book is ever published, this would work much better, and would help smooth out a few of the problems.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Masterworks: Legacy - Samantha Wilcoxson - Interview

  Today is the last of a series on nine interviews I'm sharing on the Crowvus Book Blog. These are from the authors of the short stories included in the  Masterworks  anthology by the  Historical Writers Forum . We're running through chronologically, some are video interviews, others are written. I am delighted to welcome the fantastic Samantha Wilcoxson, who is sharing the artist inspiration for her short story Legacy , as well as the appeal of James A. Hamilton, and the delights of researching. First of all, tell us a little bit about yourself, what you write (besides Masterworks!), and what inspired you to begin writing. I was inspired to write by my love of reading. After watching me read, write reviews, and keep journals for twenty years, my husband asked me why I didn’t try writing, so I did! Without really planning on it, I ended up writing historical biographical fiction. I’m drawn to a tragic tale but also to lesser known historical figures with emotive stor...

#HistFicThursdays - Apollo's Raven - Linnea Tanner - Book Blast

 If you've been following this blog for a little while, you might remember me sharing a fabulous guest post about this book in 2022 (which you can read here ). It's always great to welcome Linnea Tanner onto the Crowvus Book Blog, and I'm delighted to be taking part in her Coffee Pot Book Club book blast blog tour. So, let's meet the book... A Celtic warrior princess is torn between her forbidden love for the enemy and duty to her people. AWARD-WINNING APOLLO’S RAVEN sweeps you into an epic Celtic tale of forbidden love, mythological adventure, and political intrigue in Ancient Rome and Britannia. In 24 AD British kings hand-picked by Rome to rule are fighting each other for power. King Amren’s former queen, a powerful Druid, has cast a curse that Blood Wolf and the Raven will rise and destroy him. The king’s daughter, Catrin, learns to her dismay that she is the Raven and her banished half-brother is Blood Wolf. Trained as a warrior, Catrin must find a way to break t...

#HistFicThursdays - Strait Lace by Rosemary Hayward - Guest Post

For this week's #HistFicThursdays blog, I'm delighted to be welcoming  Rosemary Hayward  to the blog with a guest post about her new release  Strait Lace ,   as part of her  Coffee Pot Book Club  tour. Read on to discover the history surrounding this fabulous book. But first, let's meet the book... Blurb It is 1905. Edwardian England. Harriet Loxley, the daughter of a vicar and niece to a prominent Nottingham lace manufacturer, spends her days playing cricket with her brother, scouring the countryside for botanical specimens, and never missing an opportunity to argue the case for political power for women. Given the chance to visit the House of Commons, Harriet witnesses the failure of a historic bill for women’s voting rights. She also meets the formidable Pankhurst women. When Harriet gets the chance to study biology at Bedford College, London, she finds her opportunity to be at the heart of the fight. From marching in the street, to speaking to hostile c...